Astor Row, Manhattan(History)

neighborhoods_manhttan_astor_row_300x300Astor Row is the name given to 28 row houses on the south side of West 130th Street between Fifth and Lenox Avenues in the Harlem neighborhood of Manhattan, New York City, which were among the first speculative townhouses built in the area. Designed by Charles Buek, the houses were built between 1880 and 1883 in three spurts, on land that had been purchased by John Jacob Astor in 1844 for $10,000. Astor’s grandson, William Backhouse Astor, Jr., was the driving force behind the development.

The design of the three-story brick, single-family houses is unusual, in that they are set back from the street and all have front and side yards – an oddity in Manhattan – as well as wooden porches. The first group of houses, numbers 8 through 22, are freestanding pairs, while the remainder, numbers 24 through 60, are connected together at the rear.

The Astor Row houses were designated New York City Landmarks on August 11, 1981.


When William Backhouse Astor died, the houses were divided among his grandchildren, Mary, James and Sarah Van Alen. Ownership stayed in the Astor family until 1911, when the westernmost ten of the houses were sold to real estate investor Max Marx, who traded them in part for an apartment building in Washington Heights. The new owners, the Brown Realty Company, defaulted on their mortgage and the houses passed to the New York Savings Bank.

In 1920, the houses were described by a reporter for the New York Times as “one of the most attractive and exclusive home centers” in Harlem, presenting “a picture of domestic tranquility and comfort which few other blocks in the city possess.” In his 1928 novel Home to Harlem, Claude McKay described Astor Row as “the block beautiful.”

The Astor Row townhouses rented originally for $1,100 per year, and were so popular that for years there was a waiting list for them. The townhouses were occupied originally by whites, but in 1920, 20 of the 28 houses – the ten owned by New York Savings Bank, plus ten still owned by the Astors – were purchased by James Cruikshank, a real estate operator and leased to black tenants.

Generally, the houses were not well maintained, and the porches were gradually lost. In 1978, the second edition of the AIA Guide to New York City described the row as having “restrained beauty which has been tarnished by years of economic distress.” In 1981, New York City designated the entire row as landmarks, and money was raised to restore their facades, and improve their plumbing, heating systems, and electrical lines where needed. The group overseeing and financing the work included the New York Landmarks Conservancy, New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, the Vincent Astor Foundation,Manhattan Community Board 10, the Abyssinian Development Corporation, the Commonwealth Fund, the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development, and several local banks. In 1992, Ella Fitzgerald performed at a benefit at Radio City Music Hall to raise money for the restoration. By the end of the 1990s, the porches and other decorative elements had been restored to almost all the buildings on the block. In August 2009, the New York Times would write “the block is at the center of an intense but, as yet, unfinished revival of the surrounding streets in Central Harlem.”

The restoration of the row was overseen by Roberta Washington and Li/Saltzman.